Skip to content
Increase font size Decrease font size Default font size

Fife Rights

               Mental Health Law Focus 
Home arrow Case Law
Case Law PDF Print E-mail
The case reports featured on this page and in the archives are taken from the Mental Health Law Updates by Hilary Patrick, Fellow, University of Edinburgh as featured in SCOLAG, Legal Journal. We thank the author and publishers for their permission to reproduce this material. Links are provided to the full judgment on the appropriate Court Service's website where available. 
 
Mental Health (Care and Treatment) Act and related matters
Recent Cases: -
Appeal on Merits
EL (Named Person) v. Mental Health Tribunal for Scotland, Dr George Macdonald, (RMO) 30 August 2007
Law relating to the giving of reasons by tribunals
KR v Caroline Mitchell, Responsible Medical Officer and Mental Health Tribunal for Scotland, 14 May 2007
Appeal against excessive security conditions
Lothian Health Board v BM and Mental Health Tribunal for Scotland, 27 April 2007
Human Rights
R (on the application of RD) (Claimant) v Mental Health Review Tribunal (Defendant) & Secretary of State ...
 
Archive - Mental Health (Care and Treatment) Act
 
Adults with Incapacity Act
Recent Cases: -
Approved medical practitioners section 22
H, Applicant 2007 SLT (Sh Ct) 5
Intervention orders
There have been some interesting cases considering the scope of intervention orders and particularly the criterion that any order 'benefit' the adult with incapacity.
Application in respect of Mr DM, 28 April 2006
Application in respect of Mrs A, 28 April 2006
Guardianship or compulsory treatment order?
Applications in respect of EB, 1 December 2005
 
Archive - Adults with Incapacity Act
 
Discrimination
Recent Cases: -
Reasonable Adjustment
HM Prison Service v Diane Johnson [2007] 151 (34) SJ 1165
Discrimination 'on the grounds of' disability or impairment
Richmond Adult Community College v. Elizabeth McDougall [2008] EWCA Civ 4, 17 January 2008
 
Other
Crime
Reid v HM Advocate [2007] HCJAC70, 14 December 2007
Human Rights
Savage v. South Essex Partnership NHS Foundation Trust [2007] EWCA Civ 1375, 21 December 2007
JE and DE Surrey County Council and EW [2006] EWHC 3495 (Fam), 29 December2006
R (on the application of June Wright and others) and the Secretary of State for Health, the Secretary of State...
Community care
AR v Highland Council 2007 (16) SLT 513 - 516, 8 March 2007
YL (by her litigation friend the Official Solicitor) (FC) (Appellant) v Birmingham City Council and others...
Report on an investigation into complaint no 05/C/11921 against trafford Metropolitan Borough Council Local...
Special educational needs
B v Highland Council 2007 GWD 23 - 381
 
Ombudsman's Reports
State Hospital's Complaints System
Ref: report Number: 200501601: 23 January 2008
Charging for Residential Care / Transfer of House
Ref: Report Number: 200603087 21 November 2007